Hello! Today’s post comes from Alaya, who shares what she learned from going through a short sale. Alaya is the author of Hope+Cents. After paying off her own debt, she now helps others take control of their finances by offering practical tips, encouragement, and hope.
More than nine million Americans lost their homes to a short sale or foreclosure between 2006 and 2014 during and after the housing crisis, according to contemporary reports. I am part of that number.
My family bought a house in 2006 at the peak of the housing bubble. In 2012, after a job loss and a move to a new state, we needed to sell. Because our mortgage balance exceeded the home’s market value, we pursued a short sale.
Losing or giving up your home is painful. Homeownership is often framed as “the American Dream,” and when it doesn’t go as planned it can feel like a personal failure. Faced with mistakes and setbacks, you can either dwell on them or learn from them. After a short period of wallowing, I chose to learn. The lessons I took away apply to any major financial choice. Here are seven things I learned from my short sale.
Related blog posts:
- 30+ Ways to Save Thousands of Dollars Each Month
- Can You Remove PMI From Your Mortgage?
- 8 Things To Sell To Make Money
- 6 Home Buying Mistakes
These lessons can help guide you when making significant financial decisions. Below are seven key takeaways from my short sale experience.
1. Don’t Let Social Pressure Direct Your Financial Choices
I should never have bought our house. We had no down payment and carried consumer debt, but we chased ownership because “everyone” around us seemed to own homes. We wanted what others had and let social norms dictate our decision.
If you find your choices driven by what you think you should do or by comparisons to others, recognize that as social pressure. Your financial decisions should be based on what’s right for your situation, not on what others expect.
2. Don’t Make Financial Decisions You Don’t Understand
When shopping for a home, I only knew two things: I wanted a house and I needed a mortgage. I relied on the real estate agent, the mortgage broker, and other professionals to guide me, trusting they had my best interests at heart. In reality, those professionals are paid for their services and have motives of their own.
I signed paperwork I did not fully understand because I wanted the house. In hindsight, I should have learned the details of my loan terms before committing. If you don’t understand the financial product or terms you’re being offered, don’t move forward until you do. Ignorance is not a smart basis for major financial decisions.
3. “Creative” Financing Is a Red Flag
Our mortgage was a mix of risky features: a first and second mortgage, a HELOC, adjustable rates, interest-only payments, and eventually a balloon payment after a loan modification. In short, our financing was a patchwork of solutions.
All that creativity signaled one thing: we couldn’t truly afford the house. When the only way to make a purchase possible is by stretching terms, relying on future refinancing, or using other unconventional mechanisms, take it as a warning. If you must get creative to afford something, you probably can’t truly afford it.
4. Trust That Inner Voice
Throughout the purchase and the years we owned the home, I had nagging doubts. The financing made me uneasy, and my mortgage broker’s repeated suggestion to refinance after two years should have been a major red flag. Instead I silenced those concerns because I wanted the house so badly.
That inner voice is often the voice of reason. When something feels wrong, pay attention to it. Don’t ignore the warnings because desire or wishful thinking is loud.
5. Be Mindful of What You’re Sacrificing
While we never missed a mortgage payment in the six years before the short sale process began, those payments consumed a large portion of our take-home pay—at times up to 50%. We prioritized mortgage payments at the expense of college savings, retirement contributions, home maintenance, and everyday life.
If we had clearly understood the long-term cost of that lifestyle, we might have made different decisions. Count the costs carefully and be aware of what you’re sacrificing when you make major financial commitments.
6. Accept Responsibility for Your Financial Mistakes
I don’t blame the economy for losing our home. For us, the loss was the result of poor choices. Four years into owning the house—before the job loss—we worked hard to eliminate $74,000 in consumer debt, which was a major accomplishment. The short sale was not how we imagined becoming debt-free, but it did provide a way out of a situation we shouldn’t have entered.
I’m no longer ashamed of the short sale; I own my mistake. Taking responsibility for your errors lets you learn from them and move forward.
7. Pursue Your Financial Dreams on Your Own Terms
Now I rent while preparing to reenter the housing market—joining the millions of “boomerang buyers” expected to return to homeownership in the coming years. People often ask when I’ll buy again or tell me I’m wasting money on rent. Those comments can trigger social pressure, but I remind myself that I’m following my plan and timeline.
There are many ways to live a fulfilling life. Some people challenge traditional homeownership by choosing alternative lifestyles, and others opt out of ownership entirely. If owning a home isn’t your dream, that’s perfectly acceptable. Pursue your financial goals boldly, in the way that fits your life and timing—even if it differs from others’ expectations.
A Bonus Lesson: Learn Patience
Patience runs through all these lessons. Impatience pushed me into buying a house I couldn’t afford. Losing it taught me patience, and that lesson endures. I’ll apply this patience in future decisions about homeownership.
I believe mistakes need not be wasted. As one well-known entrepreneur said, “Failure is only the opportunity to begin again, only this time more wisely.” I’m ready to begin again.
Have you experienced a short sale, foreclosure, or other financial setback? What did you learn from it?